Blog Post

In Defense of the Plastic Bag

An interesting article from Green Biz on this rather controversial subject.  Take a read and see what you think. Follow the link to read the complete article


Author – Marc Gunther

“Pity the much-maligned plastic bag.

Plastic bags are being banned or taxed in cities and counties across America–just this week in Seattle, before that in San Francisco, Portland and Washington, D.C. Beginning in January, Montgomery County, MD, where I live, will impose a five-cent charge for carryout bags at all retail stores. Like most of my neighbors (median household income in the county tops $92,000) I can afford the extra nickel.

But I’m not persuaded that plastic bag bans or taxes makes sense. Here’s why.

They’re not based on science. Independent studies show that plastic bags are environmentally preferable to paper. Others suggest that, when they are reused, they are preferable to the reusable plastic or cloth sacks that many of us tote around.

Some of the arguments put forth for the bans don’t hold up. That plastic waste waste in the oceans you’ve probably read about? No, it’s not the size of Texas. Nor is it made of plastic bags.

Getting rid of carryout bags won’t lead to a long-term solution to the problem of plastic waste. Maybe instead of banning or taxing bags, we should be recycling them. That’s the argument being put forth by a company called Hilex Poly, which will recycle tens of millions of pounds of plastic bags, sacks and wraps this year, and would like to do more.

You may disagree but after digging into this subject for a while, I’m certain about only one thing: It’s complicated.

The arguments for plastic bag bans or taxes are, by now, familiar. The Montgomery County carryout bag law “is designed to improve our environment by cutting down plastic bags—a significant source of litter—which pollute our streets, streams, and playgrounds, and harm property values.” Econ 101 tells you that charging 5 cents for plastic bags creates an incentive for people to use fewer of them, and carry reusable bags instead. Proceeds go to “programs that fight litter and provide stormwater pollution control.”

Bill Hickman, who leads the Rise Above Plastics campaign at the Surfrider Foundation, an advocacy group, told me by phone: “We’re trying to stop the plastic impact on the marine environment. Plastic doesn’t biodegrade in our lifetime…Anything, single use, at the end of the day has negative effects on our environment.”

All true, but…

Studies say that plastic bags have a lighter environmental footprint than paper, and in some cases are preferable to reusable bags. A thorough life cycle analysis done in the UK by the government’s environment agency in 2006 (download PDF here) found that HDPE (high-density polyethylene, the typical lightweight plastic bags) are superior to paper because they require less energy and far less water to make and take up less space in landfill. Comparing them to reusable non woven polypropylene (PP) bags–the typical reusable bag, made in China, and sold by grocers–the study found that their impacts depend upon the number of times that plastic bags are reused. Data on this is scarce and controversial–critics of plastic say the bags are typically used just once, but the industry says they are frequently used, often as garbage bags, or to carry kids’ lunches to school, or pick up dog poop. (Banning plastic carryout bags means that people may have to buy bags for those purposes.) Focusing on the climate issue, the 120-page-long UK study says:

The paper, LDPE, non-woven PP and cotton bags should be reused at least 3, 4, 11 and 131 times respectively to ensure that they have lower global warming potential than conventional HDPE carrier bags that are not reused.


If I understand that correctly, it means that one reusable bag has the carbon footprint of 13 disposable bags that are used just once. If you use the disposable bag twice, you’ll need to deploy the reusable bag 26 times before you are ahead in terms of global warming. By the way, this doesn’t include the impact of washing the reusable bag in hot water, which is highly recommended because bacteria like E. coli and fecal coliform can thrive in reusable bags, according to this study, which, it must be said, was financed by the plastics industry.

A study from the University of California, Chico, funded by Keep California Beautiful, analyzed the U.K. studies, as well as research from Scotland, Australia and a U.S. consulting firm and found that “reusable plastic bags can have lower environmental impacts than single-use polyethylene plastic grocery bags.” But it also found traces of cadmium and lead in the reusable bags. The professor who did the study has consulted for both plastic bag and reusable bag makers. Like I said, it’s complicated.

Plastic pollution of the oceans probably isn’t as bad as you think. You can find dire stories of plastic pollution, as well as birds being strangled by plastic bags, on the websites of Surfrider and Save the Bay. Oprah Winfrey devoted a television program to the problem, saying:

The Great Pacific Garbage Patch stretches from the coast of California to Japan, and it’s estimated to be twice the size of Texas. “This is the most shocking thing I have seen,” Oprah says.

Whether Oprah has actually seen the garbage patch is anyone’s guess. But Angelicque “Angel” White, an assistant professor of oceanography at Oregon State, participated in one of the few expeditions solely aimed at understanding the abundance of plastic debris in the Pacific. He says the claim that the “Great Garbage Patch” between California and Japan is twice the size of Texas is flat wrong. OSU reports:

“There is no doubt that the amount of plastic in the world’s oceans is troubling, but this kind of exaggeration undermines the credibility of scientists,” White said. “We have data that allow us to make reasonable estimates; we don’t need the hyperbole.

According to NOAA and others, plastic debris in the oceans comes from many sources, including fishing lines, PET bottles, polyester clothing, detergent bottles, plumbing pipes, drinking straws and toothbrushes. The photo below comes from the website of a group called Heal the Bay, which crusades against plastic bags. Do you see a lot of plastic bags in the picture? Should we tax or ban all plastics because some end up as litter?”

(Follow the link at the top of the article to read more)

Related Posts

DIY Plastic Flowers
Living In A Plastic World

Living In A Plastic World – What Lies In The Future For Plastic   Plastics in

boutique bags
How to reuse your plastic bags

Here are a few tips and tricks on reusing plastic bags.  Follow the link

Store fresh cherries in a ziplock bag
How to Recycle a Zipper Bag

A useful blog on how to recycle a zipper bag - although these bags

Reducing waste over Christmas
Ways to reduce waste over Christmas

As we approach Christmas, it's good to keep thinking about our environment and how

Thinking responsibly about plastics
Thinking Responsibly About Plastic

Here is an interesting article from Henkel regarding thinking responsibly about plastics.  Please follow

Wash a zipper bag
How to Wash a Zipper Bag

Don't throw them out!  Wash them!  And here's how........... Follow the link to the original

In defense of the plastic bag
The future of plastic

We are all wondering what the future of single use plastics might be.  Here

Specialised Zipper bag
What are PP, OPP, and BOPP bags?

PP? OPP? BOPP?  What are we talking about??  Here's an informative article explaining the

Plastics recycling figures 2017

2017 Plastics recycling figures - Plastixportal "Plastics recycling in South Africa has continued to grow Johannesburg,

Plastic alternatives
Plastic Alternatives

Plastics have become a very controversial issue - here are a few interesting articles

Branded Shopping Bags Western Cape
How are Plastic Bags made?

From Sciencing comes the following information on how plastic bags are made..........  Please follow

Sandwich bag
Re-use your zipper bags

Here are some great ideas from The Secret Yumiverse   Re-use your zipper bags Proficient Packaging is

Wet Phone
How to save a wet phone using a zipper bag

Did you know you can save a wet phone using a zipper bag?  You

Zipper bag uses
Unusual uses for zipper bags

Here are some more uses of zipper bags that you might not have thought

Zipper bags in space - specimen bags
Zipper Bags in Space!

Here is an interesting article regarding the use of Bitran Bags (Zipper bags) on

Store fresh cherries in a ziplock bag
What can I use my zipper bag for?

Zipper bags are a great way to store food but there are a myriad

Zipper bags
Is Food Packaging Sustainable?

Here is a good article from a few years ago looking at the problem

Zipper bags - ziploc bags
Benefits of Plastic Packaging

Here are a few more articles surrounding the plastic packaging debate.  Enjoy the read. ______________________________________ Top

Branded Shopping Bags Western Cape
Advantages of Plastic

There is a lot of debate about the disadvantage and advantages of plastic -

Understanding the Plastic Recycling Codes

This is a very informative article from EarthEasy helping us understand the codes and

Zipper bags
You’ve been closing your ziploc bag all wrong!

Here's how to do it! Great tips from This Is Insider and Bustle ----------------------------------------- You've been

DIY Plastic Flowers
Plastic Recycling

Ever wondered about the process of recyling and what your recycled plastics can be

The future of single use plastics
The Future of Single Use Plastics

Here is something interesting on single use plastics.  Please guys, use and reuse the

Branded Shopping Bags Western Cape
Packaging Sells the Product

Here are a couple of great articles on why packaging is so important.  Enjoy

Chichen Zipper Bags
Why Branding is Important

Proficient Packaging can custom make flexible packaging to almost any size, almost any colour,  with

Zipper bags
How to Recycle Ziploc Bags

"Ziploc bags, aka sandwich bags or resealable plastic bags, are starting to be accepted

Growing seeds in a zipper bag
Growing Seeds in a Zipper Bag!

This is a great thing to do with your kids but also a great

Plastic Shade Balls
Shade Balls Help LA Save Water

The Daily Mail reported that 96 million plastic balls were released into the 175 acre

Cleaning up our oceans
Cleaning Up Our Oceans


Zipper bags
Are Zipper Bags Good For Keeping Water Out?

Can Zipper Bags For Cars Keep Flood Waters Out? According to the Insurance Council of

DIY Plastic Garden Markers - How to reuse plastic items
Plastic Flower Garden Markers

A few weeks ago we put our first seeds into the garden, just a

DIY Plastic Bag Skipping Rope - Reuse plastic bags
DIY Plastic Bag Jump Rope

"I really do make a huge effort to not get plastic bags, yet somehow

Plastic Bag Planters
How to Use Plastic Bags As Plant Containers

Planting in plastic bags is cheaper than purchasing plastic or clay pots for your

Grow lettuce in a plastic bag plant container
Growing Lettuce in a Reusable Grocery Bag

Some Lettuce Container Garden Basics It's easy to grow lettuce in plastic, reusable lunch bags,

Grow veggies in plastic bag plant containers
How to Plant Vegetables in Plastic Bag Containers

Plastic bags are an alternative to traditional planters when starting a container vegetable garden.

Ecobricks - reuse materials that you can't recycle
Ecobricking is a Deep Solution for Plastic

We envision a world where plastic is put to proper use, where we have

DIY Plastic Flowers
Ways to Upcycle Plastic Bags – Plastic Flowers

A plastic bag is cut into strips to create this plastic bag bow –

Recycle your plastic bags!
Ways To Reuse Plastic Bags

  A couple of weeks ago I had a friend visit me from California. As